Case study · June 2026 to November 2026

Nearly four in ten callers reached nobody. Now it's one in eight

The owner runs a commercial insurance brokerage in Chicagoland. Most of its customers are contractors, and they call because a job is waiting on a certificate or a quote. Nearly all of that business comes in by phone.

38% → 13% Callers who reached nobody Main line, weekday business hours · full weeks of June–July vs the four weeks from Aug 17, 2026 · one formula on both sides

Commercial insurance brokerage

Insurance · Phones + AI assistant June 2026 to November 2026

The problem

The owner runs a commercial insurance brokerage in Chicagoland. Most of its customers are contractors, and they call because a job is waiting on a certificate or a quote. Nearly all of that business comes in by phone. Before a dollar went into ads, I wanted to know how many of the people already calling reached anyone. The phone system's own call log, read one call at a time, looked a lot worse than its summary reports. In the full weeks of June and July, 2,136 calls hit the main line during weekday business hours. Half (1,077) reached a person. Nearly 4 in 10 (817, or 38%) reached nobody and left nothing. No answer, no voicemail, no message.

What I found

None of the causes showed up in a summary report. Every one of them was sitting in the call log or the account settings. - A lunch rule. A company rule sent calls between noon and 1 p.m. straight to a voicemail box. Not one of the 384 lunch-hour calls in June and July got answered live. - A clock an hour off. The owner's extension was set to a time zone that ignores daylight saving. A 9-to-6 schedule ran an hour late, and calls before 10 a.m. went to voicemail without ringing. The same setting was on 18 of 28 users. - A number that looked like spam. On outgoing calls, 10 of the firm's 32 numbers showed the placeholder caller ID "NO CALLED ID". That's the kind of label that gets a call back treated as spam.

What we did

The brokerage's people still answer first. I changed what happens when they can't. The front desk rings first. What it misses goes to an AI assistant that answers in English or Spanish. It puts callers through to the person they ask for by name, rings the whole team at once when a caller wants a quote, and otherwise takes a structured message. The support teams ring all their members at once for 35 seconds before voicemail. Before real callers ever reached the assistant, it had to pass 14 scripted test calls, including attempts to get pricing and coverage advice it has to refuse. 12 passed. The two failures got fixed and tested again. A drill took the assistant's line down on purpose and found a dead end, so we built a backup route the same day and proved it in a second drill. No customer was affected. All 28 users run on the correct time zone now. All 32 numbers show one caller identity, and 29 are registered with the major caller-reputation providers. A 911 call from an office line now alerts the front desk by text and email. Before, it alerted nobody.

The numbers

First, how I measured. A call counts as reaching a person only when one of the brokerage's staff picks up. An answer by the assistant never counts as a person. The formula and the pass bar (15% or fewer callers reaching nobody) were written down and approved before the first after-number existed. The owner's weekly call report uses the same math, over the same line and hours, on both sides. In the four full weeks from August 17, 936 calls hit the main line in business hours. 7 in 10 (651) reached a person, and those were the brokerage's own staff. About 1 in 8 (118, or 13%) reached nobody and left nothing. The rest left a voicemail or a message with the assistant. Week by week the share reaching nobody read 13%, 14%, 11% and 13%. Under the bar every week. Lunch didn't go away. It changed shape. In the week of September 7 the assistant picked up all 33 lunch-hour calls, but only 4 of those callers reached a person, and that hour still held 29 of the week's 61 calls that didn't reach a person. The support teams were confirmed on real calls in September and they're still holding. From October 12 to November 10, all 65 calls that rang a team for its full hold stopped on time and went to that team's voicemail, the way it was set up. This is the phone work behind the AI phone receptionist for contractors and home services in Chicago.

What I can't show yet

Call volume was lower after the rebuild, about 234 business-hours calls a week against about 310 in June, and I haven't pinned down why. Several changes landed in the same weeks, so these figures show what they did together. Four weeks is a start, not a full season. I also haven't measured whether the caller-ID registrations change how carriers label the numbers.

Result table

The receipts.

Metric Value Source
Callers who reached nobody and left nothing 38% → 13% Weekly call report, formula fixed in advance. 817 of 2,136 (full weeks Jun–Jul 2026) vs 118 of 936 (Aug 17 – Sep 13)
Callers who reached a person 50% → 70% Same report and calls. 1,077 of 2,136 vs 651 of 936
Lunch-hour calls answered live, June and July 0 of 384 Call-log baseline, full months Jun–Jul 2026
Lunch-hour calls picked up by the assistant 33 of 33 · 4 reached a person Weekly call report, week of 2026-09-07
Users whose schedules ran an hour late 18 of 28 → 0 Account audit with read-back, 2026-08-14
Numbers showing NO CALLED ID 10 of 32 → 0 Phone-system read-back, 2026-08-05
Scripted test calls passed before real callers 12 of 14 Acceptance calls, 2026-08-04. Failures fixed and re-tested by 2026-08-10
People alerted when 911 is dialed from an office line Nobody → front desk (text and email) Settings read before and after, 2026-08-04
Support-team calls that rang the full hold and ended as set 65 of 65 Stored call log, Oct 12 – Nov 10, 2026

You can start this yourself. Export one month of your call log and count, hour by hour, the callers who reached a person, a voicemail or nothing. Or send me the month and I'll send back the same picture this owner started with. [Send your call log to No Brainer Media](https://nobrainersmma.com/contact/).

Want this kind of result?

Book a discovery call. We'll walk your numbers.

No pitch deck. Just your CRM, your ad accounts, and a straight read on what the next 90 days could look like.